STREAMING NOW: Feast with Friends

Nutter Butter Turkeys

Want more from Genius Kitchen?

Watch on your Apple TV, Roku, or Fire TV and your iOS, Fire, or Android device.

Learn More
“This fall I'm on a quest to make recipe using Nutter Butter cookies. This recipe/craft project was inspired by The Party Animal web site.”
6 Turkeys

Ingredients Nutrition

  • 6 Nutter Butter sandwich cookies
  • 12 ounces yellow candy melts
  • 6 ounces orange candy melts
  • 6 ounces red candy melts
  • 12 edible candy eyes
  • 2 -3 pieces orange Starburst candies (beak)
  • 6 lollipop sticks
  • wax paper
  • 3 plastic bottles (melting or decorating squeeze bottle with a cap with a small-medium round opening)


  1. Draw a turkey on plain paper and make as many copies as desired. The body should be the outline of a Nutter Butter cookie.(A template appears in the photo section.) Lay a piece of wax paper over each template.
  2. Cut the Starburst candies into pointy triangles so they resemble a beak. Set aside.
  3. Add yellow candy melts to one of the decorating bottles. I lay the bottle on its side in the microwave. Microwave at 50% power for one minute. Press the bottle, mixing the candy and continue melting in 20-30 second intervals. Don't overcook the candy melts.
  4. Yellow: Fill in the body and first row of feathers with the melted yellow candy melts. Immediately press the lollipop stick into the body area. Add a little bit more yellow on top of the stick and press a Nutter Butter cookie on top. Do the same with the remaining turkeys.
  5. Orange: Melt the orange candy in bottle #2. Fill in the next row of feathers. Repeat with remaining turkeys.
  6. Red: Melt the red candy in bottle #3. Fill in the outer row of feathers. Repeat with remaining turkeys.
  7. Add the candy eyes. You can reheat the yellow candy melts or use a small amount of melted white chocolate chips. Put a dab on the back of the edible eyes and attach to the turkey body.
  8. Add the beak. Put a dab of melted candy on the back of the beak and attach right below the eyes.
  9. Snood: It's that red thing that dangles on the turkey's face. You may need to remelt the red candy. Pipe a squiggly red snood onto the turkey face.
  10. Allow turkeys to harden. Enjoy!

Watch more

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a