Sugar Free Pudding Cookies

"quick and easy to make"
 
Download
photo by justcallmetoni photo by justcallmetoni
photo by justcallmetoni
Ready In:
10mins
Ingredients:
4
Yields:
2 dozen
Serves:
24
Advertisement

ingredients

Advertisement

directions

  • Mix pudding and Bisquick.
  • Add oil and beaten egg.
  • Shape in balls and place on ungreased cookie sheet.
  • Push thumb into centre and add a dab of sugar-free jam OR criss cross with a fork.
  • Bake 350 5-8 minutes.

Questions & Replies

Got a question? Share it with the community!
Advertisement

Reviews

  1. The cookies are small and yes salty but not too bad. They need a little something but I don't know what !?!?!? Maybe splenda like the other post suggested.
     
  2. These don't really taste like "normal" cookies, but they're pretty good. We used low fat Bisquick, pistachio pudding and added a little bit of jelly to the top. I did think they were a little salty. But my 3 year old LOVED these things and kept asking me if we could make them again (also they are so easy to make, so a good one for kids to help with).
     
  3. I made the dough, and it was super salty. Then I looked at my pudding mix and it was only 2.1 oz (chocolate), so I pulled out another one (vanilla--I was out of chocolate) and it was 1.5 oz. So I just added the whole thing, figuring that hopefully the extra amount would lesson the saltiness... But then the dough was too dry, so I added a little milk to it. It was STILL very salty, so I added some Splenda, which made it edible... I think this recipe has potential... but I don't know if bisquick is the best shortcut, due to the salt content. Also, be sure to check the oz. of your pudding mix! I would rate the cookies 2 stars the way they ended up, but since I changed it so much I didn't star it.
     
  4. I doubled the recipe, and used 1 box of chocolate and 1 box of butterscotch. I have to admit I forgot to do the criss-cross, and was wondering why they didn't flatten out! But the little balls still taste great! I think you need a strong pudding flavor with this. I'm thinking about trying lemon, and then using lemon curd in the thumbprint.
     
  5. Perhaps diabetic baking is similar to low-fat baking (something I do all the time), it's an aquired taste. In any event, I've been in search of recipes to prepare suitable trays for colleagues with diabetes and borderlines and thought I would give this a try. I used banana cream sugar-free pudding and my cookies tasted like salty biscuit dough with a hint of banana. Perhaps a little Splenda would have helped. Or maybe a more strongly flavored pudding like chocolate would have worked better. Sorry for the bummer review.
     
Advertisement

RECIPE SUBMITTED BY

I live in rural central Canada. I love hockey, horses and music. My favorite cookbook is an old handwritten one of my grandmothers.
 
View Full Profile
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Find More Recipes