Nutter Butter Turkeys

Want more from Genius Kitchen?

Watch on your Apple TV, Roku, or Fire TV and your iOS, Fire, or Android device.

Learn More
“This fall I'm on a quest to make recipe using Nutter Butter cookies. This recipe/craft project was inspired by The Party Animal web site.”
6 Turkeys

Ingredients Nutrition

  • 6 Nutter Butter sandwich cookies
  • 12 ounces yellow candy melts
  • 6 ounces orange candy melts
  • 6 ounces red candy melts
  • 12 edible candy eyes
  • 2 -3 pieces orange Starburst candies (beak)
  • 6 lollipop sticks
  • wax paper
  • 3 plastic bottles (melting or decorating squeeze bottle with a cap with a small-medium round opening)


  1. Draw a turkey on plain paper and make as many copies as desired. The body should be the outline of a Nutter Butter cookie.(A template appears in the photo section.) Lay a piece of wax paper over each template.
  2. Cut the Starburst candies into pointy triangles so they resemble a beak. Set aside.
  3. Add yellow candy melts to one of the decorating bottles. I lay the bottle on its side in the microwave. Microwave at 50% power for one minute. Press the bottle, mixing the candy and continue melting in 20-30 second intervals. Don't overcook the candy melts.
  4. Yellow: Fill in the body and first row of feathers with the melted yellow candy melts. Immediately press the lollipop stick into the body area. Add a little bit more yellow on top of the stick and press a Nutter Butter cookie on top. Do the same with the remaining turkeys.
  5. Orange: Melt the orange candy in bottle #2. Fill in the next row of feathers. Repeat with remaining turkeys.
  6. Red: Melt the red candy in bottle #3. Fill in the outer row of feathers. Repeat with remaining turkeys.
  7. Add the candy eyes. You can reheat the yellow candy melts or use a small amount of melted white chocolate chips. Put a dab on the back of the edible eyes and attach to the turkey body.
  8. Add the beak. Put a dab of melted candy on the back of the beak and attach right below the eyes.
  9. Snood: It's that red thing that dangles on the turkey's face. You may need to remelt the red candy. Pipe a squiggly red snood onto the turkey face.
  10. Allow turkeys to harden. Enjoy!

Watch more

Join the Conversation

  • all
  • reviews
  • tweaks
  • q & a